All articles

Overtrading: when trading more starts to cost you money

Every extra trade pays a fixed cost and tends to be of lower quality than the ones you were looking for. How to spot overtrading in your own data, what the research shows and which rules rein it in

What counts as overtrading

Overtrading is trading more than your plan justifies: more trades, more hours or more instruments than you had decided, without the market offering more of the opportunities you look for.

The benchmark is your plan. A scalper can take forty trades a day within their method. A swing trader who takes five in a morning has probably left theirs. What matters is the distance between what you do and what you had planned.

How it shows in your data

Overtrading leaves marks you can count:

  • Number of trades: far more than in your normal sessions.
  • Time between trades: entries come closer and closer together.
  • Hours and instruments: trades outside the hours or markets in your plan.
  • Costs: commissions and slippage weigh more and more on the result.
  • Quality: a smaller share of trades meets your entry conditions.

It tends to show up at recognizable moments: after a loss, to win it back; after a good run, when size and frequency creep up; and in slow sessions, when being flat starts to feel long.

What the research shows

Brad Barber and Terrance Odean studied the accounts of 66,465 households at a discount broker between 1991 and 1996 (Journal of Finance, 2000). Those who traded most earned 11.4% a year, while the market returned 17.9%. They were stock investors, not day traders, but the study shows something that applies to anyone: every trade pays a cost, and in their sample trading more did not make up for it.

Itzhak Ben-David, Justin Birru and Viktor Prokopenya looked at retail forex traders (NBER, 2016). After a winning week they increased their size and traded more, even though past results did not predict the next ones. The effect was stronger among beginners.

And in Taiwan, Brad Barber, Yi-Tsung Lee, Yu-Jane Liu and Terrance Odean found that fewer than 1% of day traders made money predictably once fees were taken out (Journal of Financial Markets, 2014).

What an extra trade costs

An illustrative example. Each trade costs you $10 in commissions and slippage. Your plan is 4 trades a day and you take 12. That is $80 more a day before you make anything. Over 20 sessions, $1,600.

And that is only the fixed cost. The extra trades also tend to be the weakest: entries outside your setup, at hours you know less well, decided faster.

A useful question for reviewing any session:

Which of today’s trades would you have taken if you could only make three?

Rules that rein it in

Illustrative examples. Set the numbers using your good sessions as the reference:

  1. A maximum number of trades per session. Set before the open. When you reach it, you close the platform.
  2. Fixed trading hours. Outside that window there are no trades, even if something shows up.
  3. A short list of setups. If the entry is not on the list, it does not count as an opportunity.
  4. A cap for good days too. Once you reach a set profit, you size down or stop.
  5. A review at the close. Count how many trades followed the plan and how much you paid in costs. One number a week is enough to see the trend.

Where OX212 comes in

OX212 knows your normal pace: how many trades you take and how often. When you trade much faster or much more often than usual for you, it tells you so with your own data. If you have allowed it, it stops you when you reach the maximum number of trades per day you set in your plan.

Editorial content on decision processes. This is not investment advice or a psychological assessment.

Keep reading

OX212 reads your behavior while you trade

It sees the breach of your plan coming and protects your account before the damage compounds

From $49/mo

Get started with OX212