All articles

Position size after a loss: why it breaks and how to set it

After a loss, the size of the next trade tends to move. The numbers behind it, what the research shows and three ways to set it before you need to

The trade after a loss

Working out size is simple: you decide how much you accept losing if the stop is hit and divide it by what each contract loses at that stop. The hard part is sticking to that sum when the previous trade has just gone wrong.

After a loss, size tends to move in one of two directions. Up, to recover sooner. Or sharply down, until you trade so small that the strategy stops making sense. Either way, the previous result is what decides the size.

The arithmetic of recovering

Losing and recovering are not symmetrical. What you lose is measured on a bigger account than the one you have left to win it back:

  • You lose 10%: you need to gain 11.1% to get back to where you started.
  • You lose 20%: you need 25%.
  • You lose 30%: you need 42.9%.
  • You lose 50%: you need 100%.

Sizing up to recover sooner also speeds up the fall if the big trade goes wrong. Doubling size after every loss has a name, martingale. It comes from betting and is a well-known way to empty an account.

On a funded account, the room gets tighter

An illustrative example. You have $2,500 of room before the maximum drawdown and you risk $250 per trade, 10% of that room. On a bad day you lose $1,000. You have $1,500 left, and the same $250 is now 16.7% of it. If you also size up to $500 to win it back, each trade risks a third of your room.

On an account with a floor, keeping the same size after a loss already means risking a bigger share of what you have left.

What the research shows

Risk rising after a loss has been measured. Joshua Coval and Tyler Shumway saw it in professional futures traders in Chicago (Journal of Finance, 2005): those who lost in the morning took above-average risk in the afternoon more often than those who had gained.

Size moves after wins too. Itzhak Ben-David, Justin Birru and Viktor Prokopenya found that retail forex traders increased their size after a winning week, even though past results did not predict the next ones (NBER, 2016).

The practical conclusion works in both directions: if your size changes with the last result, it should be because your plan says so.

Three ways to set it before you need to

What matters is deciding the rule before the open, with a cool head, in a way you can check afterwards. Three common approaches:

  1. Fixed risk in money. You always risk the same amount per trade, whatever happens. It is the simplest to monitor.
  2. Risk as a percentage of the account. You risk a fixed percentage of the current balance. After a loss, the amount goes down on its own; when the account grows, it goes up.
  3. Base size after a loss. You define a normal size and a smaller base size. After a loss, the next trade goes on at base size. You return to normal on a written condition, for example a winning trade or the next session.

None of them suits everyone. The one you choose has to fit your strategy and the rules of your account. With any of the three, the size of the trade after a loss is decided before the loss happens.

How to check whether it happens to you

Go through your last 50 trades. Separate the ones that came right after a loss and compare their average size with the rest. Do the same with the ones that followed a win. If either group stands out from your average, you know where to look.

Where OX212 comes in

In OX212 you declare your plan for each account, with a maximum size and a base size for after a loss. OX212 compares every size with that plan and with what is normal for you. After a loss, it reminds you of your base-size rule. If you still open bigger, it sees it at that moment and, if you have allowed it, pauses the account. Every intervention is recorded in a sealed receipt, open to independent verification.

Editorial content on risk and decision processes. This is not investment advice.

Keep reading

OX212 reads your behavior while you trade

It sees the breach of your plan coming and protects your account before the damage compounds

From $49/mo

Get started with OX212